Scientists
have discovered that two chemicals, AICAR and GW1516,
may produce some of
the physical benefits of exercise.
Exercise,
as stated though out this web site, is one of the best things you can
do for yourself. It has multiple physical and psychological health
benefits. It does involve work and determination (which add to the
psychological benefits). Most everyone would rather take a pill than
run six miles.
How
does it work?When
we exercise, our muscle cells make several adaptations to improve our
physical performance. There are multiple chemical signals that tell our
cells what adaptations to make. Two of the many signal receptors on our
muscle cells' surfaces are AMPK and PPAR
d (PPAR-delta).
PPARd/GW1516In
mice that are genetically programmed to have an overactive PPAR
d
receptor, it was found that even without physical conditioning, their
endurance was nearly twice as much as normal mice. The
GW1516 chemical
stimulates the PPAR
d
receptor. Mice that have been given GW1516 were able to run 60-75%
longer and farther. This chemical has been shown to be active in humans
as well.
Scientists found that GW1516 given to mice
mostly had
beneficial effects in the fast-twitch muscles (quick strong
contractions) over the slow-twitch muscles (repetitive endurance
contractions). They also found that just giving the drug to mice did
not increase their running endurance. However, when these mice also
were made to exercise and given GW1516, there was an increase of
slow-twitch
muscle fibers by 38%. Also, muscle cells made more
mitochondria
(the
power plants of cells).
There
are several other genes that were activated when the mice were given
GW1516 and made to exercise. Some of these regulate the storage and
uptake of fat. Others caused muscle remodeling and an increase
in
aerobic metabolism capacity.
AMPK/AICARAMPK
is another receptor on muscle cell surfaces that is activated by
exercise.
AICAR can be taken orally and turns on the AMPK
receptor. It has been shown to increase endurance in mice by 45%.
After
treating mice with AICAR for 4 weeks, some fat mass was reduced and
oxygen consumption (i.e.
metabolism) was increased. They
also were able
to run faster and longer without any physical training.
The combination of AICAR and
GW1516When
GW1516 and AICAR were given together in mice that did not
exercise, 40% of the genes were activated that were turned on
in
the mice that both exercised and took GW1516. Most of these genes
affect muscle performance. Thus, many exercise
signals were activated in the cells even though the mice had not
exercised.
Side EffectsThese
chemicals are still in the experimental stage. Not until humans take
these drugs on a large scale will their side effects be fully known.
These
chemicals may open the door to yet another performance enhancing drug.
For the
ultracompetative athlete who wants to win at all costs, enhanced
physical endurance in a pill would be very appealing. One of the main
scientists who worked on this study has developed a urine test to
detect the
drug. He has made it available to the International
Olympic Committee.
CommentsTaken
by themselves, AICAR produces some of the beneficial effects of
exercise on muscle cells. GW1516 in combination with exercise also
produces beneficial effects on muscles. The scientists who studied this
suggest that medicines that mimic the effects of exercise may play a
role in treating muscle diseases such as wasting or frailty and in
obesity. As noted above, this is all still experimental. The full
benefits and side effects are yet to be known.
Although
these researchers have discovered how to positively activate many of
the cellular signals that are present during exercise, it is unlikely
that these drugs can completely induce the positive effects of
regular exercise.
The psychological improvements
would almost certainly be left out. There is a myriad of nerve signals
in the brain that are activated during exercise. Endorphins produce the
"runner's high" that cause some people to say that they are "addicted"
to running or other exercise.
Sports and exercise
give people a sense of accomplishment and an outlet for stress. They
can also foster a positive competitive drive which helps people to be
successful in life. There is a great deal of social interaction that
goes into playing sports and exercising as well. None of this can be
replaced by a pill. (At least not yet.)
For
those who are severely obese and cannot/will not exercise, a "exercise
pill" may be of great benefit. However, for everyone who can, regular
exercise will likely remain a cornerstone of health and happiness.